Wednesday, February 25, 2009

Scottish Government's £10m in-house lawyers make their mark against legal reforms & public access to justice

ScottishGovernmentScottish Government – more lawyers than ever. While many in Scotland face access to justice restrictions or problems in obtaining legal aid, the SNP controlled Scottish Government has no such problems with the legal profession, as figures reveal the SNP administration has recruited a hugely expensive and all time high army of in-house lawyers & legal firms to work for the Government.

The Government Legal Service for Scotland, otherwise known as GLSS, boasts nearly two hundred in-house lawyers working across the full range of Government Departments and allegedly 'independent' institutions such as the Scottish Law Commission, the Scottish Legal Complaints Commission, even the Scottish Parliament, and many others.

2007 GLSS salariesAccording to salary scales & statistics from 2007, the costs and numbers of lawyers involved in GLSS operations has risen sharply since the Scottish National Party took office, showing a rise from 114 posts to at least 175, and an almost doubling in cost to the Scottish taxpayer from £5 million to around £10 million pounds today. However, as if nearly two hundred strong army of lawyers weren't enough to defend the Scottish Government from all & sundry, it is also the case that additional legal teams & private legal firms are contracted in on almost "blank cheque" operations, as one Justice Department insider put it today.

From the GLSS own promotion, the current levels of salaries and posts for 2009 are as follows :

GLSS 2009The GLSS offers excellent working conditions and career prospects, supported by a commitment to training and development. Salaries are in the range of £27,153 to £32,583 for Legal Officers and £36,203 to £46,700 for Principal Legal Officers, the main recruitment grades. Appointments are permanent and pensionable. There are part-time and job-share opportunities as well as other flexible working arrangements. The current salary for trainees is £17,000 in the first year, rising to £18,955 in the second year.

However, a full range of unmentioned perks for these in-house lawyers exist, where for instance, each solicitor's professional indemnity insurance subscription (required by the Law Society for a valid practising certificate), which can vary up to several thousand pounds each, levied as a result on claims against 'crooked lawyers' to the Master Insurance Policy, is also paid out of public funds as an 'expense'.

A Scottish Government spokesman refused to comment on why the current administration felt it needed to waste many more millions of pounds of taxpayers money on yet more lawyers & legal affairs, however an insider to the Justice Department condemned the GLSS as an unaccountable costly branch of Government which has deliberately put the boot into many legal reforms over the years, and more so since the last election.

"There is little that can be done by Ministers, the Government, Parliament, you name it, if solicitors working at the GLSS issue advice opposing assisting an individual on something like seeking an inquiry into a sudden death, or a medical scandal, or even such things as reform of the legal profession or legal services."

"Everyone knows that much of the advice "not to act" on occasions where the public have asked for help to their MSP, comes solely as a result of professional bias against the issue being discussed".

The source went on to claim that many of the private legal firms brought in under contract by the Scottish Government operated without much worry over financial accountability :”When law firms are brought in to do contract work the costs of what they are doing go through the roof !”.

In professional circles, it is widely known the GLSS have been involved in many inquiries & scandals which have taken years to resolve in Scotland, ranging from the Shirley McKie fingerprint scandal, where advice from the GLSS prolonged the then Scottish Executive's cover up of why fingerprints were misidentified by the then Scottish Criminal Records Office, and onto other serious issues such as the contaminated blood products scandal, where to this day, the Government's in house legal teams are seemingly attempting to wait out the issue so those victims who were caught up in the affair die off.

Notably for the issues which I campaign on, it seems the GLSS have been 'very active' in opposing parliamentary and government assistance to those who fell victim to the Scots legal profession, and recent information shown to me by one MSP, which came from the GLSS and was marked "not for disclosure to the constituent" urged the politician "to find a way out of involvement in the constituent's case", which strangely enough, related to the Law Society of Scotland and several crooked lawyers.

Advice to MSPsAdvice to MSPs : ditch your constituents. An example of advice offered to one SNP politician who was told by a Government lawyer to ditch their constituent simply because the issue related to dealings with crooked lawyers and the Law Society of Scotland. To MSP : “I suggest you find a way out of any further involvement in your constituent’s case and do not reply to any further letters from him on this or any other matter.”. The lawyer in question, had not only ruined the constituent’s finances, he had conducted a long campaign of harassment allegedly even using contacts in the Police to hound his former client’s family out of their home.

The following is a description from the Scottish Government's website on the current state of the Government Legal Service for Scotland. No mention however of the role it plays in stymieing the public's access to justice, on everything from medical scandals, child abuse cases, construction & planning application scandals, scandals involving the legal profession, and even the revelations of material under Freedom of Information requests ....

Which part of helping Scots to gain access to justice and human rights does this lot play ? they seem little more than guardians for the professions, adept at preventing ordinary people getting help with problems involving vested interests rather than helping us all along ….

Government Legal Service for Scotland (Lawyers in Government)

The Government Legal Service for Scotland ( GLSS) is a professional community of lawyers in government in Scotland.

It exists in order to -

* raise awareness of the roles of public service lawyers and of the GLSS member offices
* promote contacts, share information and develop skills and knowledge among staff in its member offices
* provide shared services to member offices and their staff.

who we are

The member GLSS offices are -

* Office of the Solicitor to the Scottish Executive
* Legal Secretariat to the Lord Advocate
* Office of the Solicitor to the Advocate General
* Legal Secretariat to the Advocate General
* Scottish Parliament's Directorate of Legal Services
* Scottish Law Commission

The GLSS also provides legal staff to (for example) the Crofters' Commission, the Lord President's private office and the Scottish Land Court. It works closely with others, in particular with the Office of the Scottish Parliamentary Counsel ( OSPC), responsible for drafting most Scottish legislation.

uniqueness of GLSS work

Lawyers working with the GLSS and its related offices are engaged on a wide variety of interesting and intellectually challenging work, much of it unique to government. A central theme is the development and implementation of new law. Preparation of legislation for both the Scottish Parliament and Westminster forms a large part of the workload. It also includes handling high profile, sensitive litigation and dealing with novel devolution or other constitutional problems. The work of the GLSS is often newsworthy, and it is always necessary to consider political consequences and potential sensitivities or wider implications. Given the nature of the work, the GLSS lawyer has a very influential role and a real opportunity to make a difference.

GLSS lawyers are involved in almost all aspects of government - whether it be resolving legal problems in policy development, operational delivery of services to the public or the smooth running of corporate services. European Union, human rights and devolution law and practice form a constant background to government legal work.

GLSS lawyers may also be seconded to work in policy posts, particularly in areas which relate to legal policy such as the Scottish Executive's Justice Department or Constitutional Policy Unit. GLSS lawyers also provide support for public inquiries. Lawyers working at the Scottish Law Commission contribute directly to the Commission's aims of improving, simplifying and updating the law of Scotland and lawyers at the Scottish Parliament are central to the Parliament's work as a legislature.

Opportunities also exist for secondment to one of the EU institutions or a placement with an external organisation, whether in the public or private sector. This has, on occasions, involved temporary postings to places as far afield as Indonesia.

One aspect of working practice which differs markedly from many private sector firms is that lawyers in the GLSS tend to move between different areas of work over the course of their careers. They are viewed as specialist government lawyers, rather than specialising in a particular subject area for lengthy periods of time. This approach means that lawyers develop transferable skills and are able to deal with novel subjects which frequently arise.

Office of the Solicitor to the Scottish Executive

OSSE is the largest office in the GLSS, providing legal services to the Scottish Executive and its agencies. This covers a very wide spectrum including litigation and tribunal work, property and commercial law and procurement advice, instructing Bills and drafting subordinate legislation, including implementation of EC Directives. These responsibilities include the provision of legal advice to the Scottish Ministers. A major focus of OSSE's advisory and legislation work is in ensuring that Ministers act always within the powers conferred on them by the devolution settlement and that Executive Bills presented to the Scottish Parliament are within the legislative competence of the Parliament. This aspect of the office's work invariably involves consideration of human rights issues.

OSSE reports to the Lord Advocate and Solicitor General for Scotland who are the principal ministerial advisers to the Scottish Executive on legal matters. It currently has 109 lawyers, plus a range of support staff.

For more information see

Legal secretariat to the lord advocate

The Lord Advocate and the Solicitor General for Scotland (formally known as the Scottish Law Officers) are the principal legal advisers to the Scottish Executive. One of their roles is to provide legal opinions to Scottish Ministers in cases where advice at the highest level is required. Both are members of the Executive and the Lord Advocate attends Cabinet.

The function of the Legal Secretariat is to support the Scottish Law Officers in this role, for instance by researching and helping to draft opinions and by providing advice on other matters referred to the Law Officers. The work very often involves complex issues of human rights and constitutional law. The Legal Secretariat also has an important role in maintaining close liaison with OSSE which provides most of the legal advice required by the Executive and with their UK counterparts.

The Legal Secretariat currently comprises three lawyers, plus support staff.

Office of the solicitor to the Advocate General

The Office of the Solicitor to the Advocate General for Scotland ( OSAG) is part of the Department of Constitutional Affairs, which is a Department of the UK Government. The Advocate General is the Law Officer responsible for advising UK Ministers on Scots law. OSAG is responsible for advising UK Government Departments operating in Scotland on all matters relating to Scots law. It instructs UK legislation applying in Scotland and represents its client Departments in litigation before the Scottish courts. It has special expertise in administrative law and in the division of legal powers between the devolved Scottish institutions and their UK counterparts.

The Office also provides support for the Advocate General in carrying out his statutory functions under the devolution settlement. Devolution issues arising in the Scottish courts are intimated to the Advocate General and OSAG staff co-ordinate their consideration in Whitehall and arrange for any intervention which the Advocate General considers appropriate. Legal staff also consider legislation which comes before the Scottish Parliament so as to identify any issues about competence which may arise. These issues are then considered in co-operation with Cabinet Office and other Whitehall legal advisers.

The Office comprises 18 lawyers, plus support staff.

legal secretariat to the advocate general

The Advocate General is one of the three UK Law Officers, along with the Attorney General and Solicitor General, and is the principal legal adviser to the UK Government on Scots law. The Legal Secretariat is a small team of three lawyers based in London. They assist the Advocate General in preparation of Law Officers' opinions (many of which are prepared jointly with the Law Officers for England and Wales), and support him in relation to Parliamentary business, Cabinet committee meetings, correspondence, speeches and other general business. The legal staff take part in Cabinet Office committees of officials and other Whitehall co-ordinating meetings on European law, human rights and devolution.

For more about OSAG and the Legal Secretariat see

Scottish Parliament's directorate of legal services

GLSS staff in the Directorate gain experience as parliamentary lawyers. The work is diverse. Much of it is legislative - helping produce non-Executive Bills, advising the Presiding Office on legislative competence, scrutinising Minister-made subordinate legislation. There is also work on procedures and governance such as advising the Scottish Parliamentary Corporate Body which is responsible for providing the Parliament's property, staff and services. Most of the lawyers work not only with colleagues in the Parliament staff group but also with Members across the parliamentary political spectrum, in committees and other forums.

The Directorate has 13 lawyers, and four support staff.

For more information see

Scottish Law Commission

The Scottish Law Commission is an independent statutory body which recommends reforms to improve, simplify and update the law. Its recommendations, if accepted, are generally implemented through legislation in the Scottish or Westminster Parliaments. Lawyers seconded from the GLSS play an important role in managing and contributing to the development of legal policy on all of its reform projects.

There are currently five senior GLSS lawyers working at the Commission. The Commission also recruits legal assistants for assignment to particular projects. For more information about the Commission and its work see


opportunities for lawyers in the GLSS

Throughout some 175 legal posts in the various offices staffed by GLSS lawyers, the GLSS provides excellent opportunities for a varied and stimulating career.

GLSS lawyers are all civil servants and recruitment is by way of open competition. Vacancies are advertised on the Scottish Executive website as well as in the national press ( Assignment to a particular post takes place after recruitment and is determined by the business needs of the different offices, taking into account, so far as practicable, the experience and preferences of successful candidates.

trainee solicitors

The GLSS offers a varied legal trainee programme which is advertised on the Executive's website and in the national press, as well as through its participation in annual law fairs run by the main Scottish Law Schools. The training covers a wide range of government legal work, from core professional areas - such as contract, litigation and commercial law - to specialist advisory work for departments and associated agencies. Trainees have four six-month placements during their traineeship. There may therefore be opportunities to work with the Legal Secretariat to the Lord Advocate, the Office of the Solicitor to the Advocate General, the Scottish Parliament or the Scottish Law Commission as well as a short placement in the Legal Secretariat to the Advocate General in London. There is also an exchange scheme under which some trainees may spend six months with a private sector firm.

pay and conditions

The GLSS offers excellent working conditions and career prospects, supported by a commitment to training and development. Salaries are in the range of £27,153 to £32,583 for Legal Officers and £36,203 to £46,700 for Principal Legal Officers, the main recruitment grades. Appointments are permanent and pensionable. There are part-time and job-share opportunities as well as other flexible working arrangements. The current salary for trainees is £17,000 in the first year, rising to £18,955 in the second year.

summer placement scheme

The GLSS operates a summer placement scheme offering law students one month's paid work experience, normally between June and September. The scheme is open to students in the fourth year of their degree or currently completing their diploma and is advertised each year through the university Law Schools and Faculties.

for further information contact: Ann McKenzie, GLSS Secretariat, G B(N), Victoria Quay, Edinburgh EH6 6QQ Tel no. 0131 244 0815 or email


Anonymous said...

The email from the GLSS employee - nice money if you can get it - to the MSP is a clear and unwarranted interference with due process, denying their constituent any proper or meaningful access to justice.

Has the MSP reported the GLSS instruction to the Presiding Officer in Parliament, the authorities or the national press I wonder. If not, why not?

Peter Cherbi said...

No report of the email has been made to the Presiding Officer that I am aware of.

The MSP however assures me this kind of advice has been given out from time to time to other MSPs at Holyrood ...

Anonymous said...

and more importantly the poor bloody constituent is paying their taxes to pay the lawyers salary & benefits who is telling their politician not to reply to them !

fucking disgusting if you don't mind me saying so !

Anonymous said...

what the hell is going on here ? is Alex Salmond running a holiday camp for lawyers ?

Anonymous said...

Just hang on a minute Peter.
This msp has probably committed a breach of confidentiality by handing those emails out and right now the GLSS will be going through their emails to see which msp is involved. I'd imagine someone is going to get into a lot of trouble over it, but I doubt anything will happen to the GLSS solicitor as he/she will be protected by legal professional privilege.
Your source might get it in the neck this time,Mr Cherbi.

Anonymous said...

why no email replies from the MSP ? and was the poor constituent informed what happened ?

Peter Cherbi said...

# Anonymous @ 4.48pm

Good luck to them if they want to try.

This is no backbencher MSP so lets see who is more important to the party, some overpaid lawyer who is playing with Scots access to their elected representatives, or a fairly well respected politician.

#Anonymous @ 4.58pm

The MSP is still helping the constituent concerned.

Anonymous said...

FYI "In House lawyers" are usually the dregs of the profession who no one in their right mind would ever have anything to do with.

You should see some of those GLSS idiots advice when it came to PFI.One Labour msp claimed privately they had obviously been bribed !

Anonymous said...

Peter ! You must have MacAskill so round the bend he has to hire 175 lawyers to defend against you !

keep it up !

Anonymous said...

oh and good on the msp who stuck with his constituent DESPITE BEING TOLD NOT TO

Anonymous said...

I suspect someone will end up in a lot of trouble over those emails Mr Cherbi and I don't think legal professional privilege will protect them from the content.

I take it you will keep us updated on what happens next.

Anonymous said...

The obvious question now would be how many times has a lawyer advised an msp to leave their constituent high & dry ?

I would think its more common than one may imagine but all the same very wrong.

Anonymous said...

I see the whiter than white Scottish Law Commission is among those under the control of the GLSS.

I take it this is why it takes a decade for SLC proposals to make it to paper ?

Anonymous said...

that monster clubbed 21 seal pups to death but if he clubbed 21 lawyers he would have been a bloody hero !

maybe he cam club the lawyers to even things up lol

Anonymous said...

Hmm very interesting again as usual although I think I know a few at Holyrood who would take great exception to that kind of advice !

Don't believe the lawyers are in control of everything Peter.Sometimes they can be given a good fright just like you keep doing to them.

Keep up the good work.

Anonymous said...

The feeling seems to be this GlSS has become a bit of a monster for the legal profession and I agree.

Its also no coincidence its former boss Richard Henderson retired and moved straight to the Law Society as its President to keep everything as it has aye been.

Anonymous said...

Fair enough this is happening on the SNP's watch but its clearly been going on for years since you mentioned what do you suggest doing about it ?

Anonymous said...

bring back the rope for these lawyers someone !

Anonymous said...

Good one but when I worked at the Parliament,I saw letters coming in from private legal firms suggesting the same and guess what - msps usually end up dropping their constituents in droves.

I would not trust the msp's motives whoever he or she is.

Anonymous said...

All very interesting as ever Mr Cherbi.

I think whoever emailed the msp from the email is a shit but I think you will find many of those types within the GLSS.

I remember very well a relative of mine trying to complain against a planning review and she received a letter from the Scottish Executive's Justice Department saying if she didn't drop her challenge they intended to sue her for the cost of the investigation which covered everything up as you would expect.
The part which the GLSS wanted covered up was a Councillor taking bribes from a local building contractor probably because the Councillor is good friends with a msp who was a minister at the time.

They get their money very easy for dirty tricks.

Peter Cherbi said...

# Anonymous @ 12.03am

Replace the Justice Secretary and slim down the GLSS to under 100 posts.Make them pay their own negligence insurance instead of the taxpayer footing the bill.

# Anonymous @ 9.53am

Thanks for your comment and I have heard of such letters. I understand one MSP was threatened with being sued by a lawyer didn't want her helping a ruined constituent.

The Law Society then joined in and claimed there was no case to answer despite the constituent ending up losing their home.

If you have any further examples, please contact me.

#Anonymous @ 10.49am

Thanks for your comment. Please contact me with more details of what happened in the case you mention, as I'm sure what happened to your relative has happened to many others.

Anonymous said...

Tip : You should have had the email to the msp in your headline.

Hope to hear more on this later on.

Anonymous said...

Presumably the GLSS will be more cautious in the advice they write down in emails or paper now there is the prospect of it being leaked to media.

Good work Mr Cherbi.I hope others take note of what happened here.

Anonymous said...

“I suggest you find a way out of any further involvement in your constituent’s case and do not reply to any further letters from him on this or any other matter.”

Its a good thing the msp thought otherwise but still whoever wrote this and supported it as a policy should be sacked and publicly named and shamed.

Anonymous said...

no surprise to me what I read here

a few msps are lawyers anyway so they will stick with their pals advice and drop anyone they dont want to help

Anonymous said...

I do wish the newspapers would be more brave in exposing this kind of corruption because clearly someone has overstepped the mark in interfering between a voter and their elected rep.
I would call it a criminal act but I am sure the lawyer concerned will be able to dodge out of that one easily.

Anonymous said...

well written as others have said and I think its quite clear we are all getting ripped off with 200 lawyers working in cushy well paid jobs in government

Anonymous said...

Where did you get those 2007 figures from ?

Looks like a scandal anyway and you are correct we dont need 175 lawyers at the taxpayers expense !

Anonymous said...

These lawyers are civil servants too ?
What a rip off !

Poirot said...

Good sources make a good article Peter and you certainly seem to have a bit of both from what I just read in your email ! All the best.

Anonymous said...

If I were the MSP I'd go round to that lawyer and ring his neck.Who the hell are these lawyres to interfere between a member of th e public and their elected politician ?

Anonymous said...

If I were that msp I would have went round and punched this lawyer in the nose !
I hope the constituent gets a fair hearing and help on whatever problem they have.

jm said...

I am really bothered about that email Mr Cherbi.How did you come by it? My msp also left me after 2 years of fighting the law society about a complaint and I'm beginning to suspect the same happened.