Tuesday, May 26, 2015

TRIBUTE TO A TRIBUNE: As Lord Gill stands down, courts salute career of top judge who used Scotland Act loophole against Holyrood over calls to declare judicial interests

Top judge who resisted transparency praised for long career. FAREWELL tributes have been paid in court today to Scotland's top judge, Lord President Lord Brian Gill as he retires after serving three years as Lord Justice General, accumulating some 21 years on the bench.

Brian Gill – now aged 73, was Lord Justice Clerk from 2001 until 2012 when he was appointed Lord President after the retirement of Lord Hamilton.

At a ceremony earlier today in the First Division courtroom in Parliament House, a full bench of judges heard Lord Carloway, the Lord Justice Clerk, say that Lord Gill's legal career had spanned half a century and "his distinguished path from passing advocate in 1967 to Lord President is a matter of record if not legend".

Lord Carloway added: "We will all miss his leadership and his friendship on and off the bench. He will be a great loss to Parliament House. However, on behalf of the bench and staff, we all wish him well in retirement, knowing he has a life beyond the law."

Gill had a vision of an inclusive approach, along with a deep concern for the common man and woman, said Lord Carloway - who only a few weeks ago gave a speech accusing lawyers of derailing his own plan to abolish corroboration – a safeguard in Scots law where evidence must be corroborated by two independent sources.

Speaking at a conference of Commonwealth Law Reform Agencies in Edinburgh, Lord Carloway said that his proposals to abolish corroboration has been met with “real hostility” from some lawyers.

Lord Carloway said: “Reactionary or excessively defensive forces among the legal profession can, and often do, behave in a manner obstructive to progressive law reform, especially where there is transparent perceived financial self-interest.”

As it turns out, Lord Gill, along with just about every other member of the judiciary opposed the removal of corroboration. In November 2013, Lord Gill gave testimony to the Scottish Parliament’s Justice Committee who were considering the abolishment of corroboration.

Subsequently, the Justice Committee voted against abolishment of corroboration and the politically motivated plan to abolish it – led by the Crown Office, Police Scotland and the now sacked Justice Secretary Kenny MacAskill - was thankfully abandoned.

James Wolffe QC, Dean of Faculty, praised Lord Gill's commitment to Scotland's outward-looking legal heritage.

Wolffe – who’s wife is Court of Session judge Lady Sarah Wolffe – referred to court reports of the past 20 years as "filled with your judgments, expounding and applying the law in your characteristically lapidary prose".

Mr Wolffe - who heads the Faculty of Advocates – the governing body for advocates recently revealed to have plundered the land titles to Parliament House - added: "Your presidency of this court has been characterised by a major campaign of civil justice reform... it aims to effect nothing less than a transformation in the way that we secure civil justice in this country in the 21st century."

Referring to music - another of Lord Gill's great passions, Wolffe recalled that he had written an anthem, "Populus Sion", for the Faculty of Advocates Choir which was performed by the choir, under his direction, in the Basilica of St Peter in Rome in 2006.

Wolffe added: "I speak on behalf of the Faculty, as its Dean, in expressing the hope that, as the law releases its claims upon you, as you lay aside the burdens of office, you will find great enjoyment doing the things about which you care and spending time with the people whom you love"

Alistair Morris, President of the Law Society of Scotland, hailed Lord Gill as one of the most distinguished, pragmatic and reforming holders of the offices of Lord Justice Clerk and Lord President.

Morris, who recently wrote in the media about a rigged Law Society poll claiming lawyers were well regarded - said Gill had brought great judgment to the posts, and, importantly, "Glaswegian wit and good humour."

Lord Gill, who devised the sweeping, now sadly watered down reforms to the civil courts as authored in his Scottish Civil Courts Review - thanked everyone for their kind words, which "mean more to me than I can say".

He said he had enjoyed two great privileges in his career.

The first was to be admitted to the Faculty of Advocates, through which he had the good fortune to make a living doing what he loved, and to make "many and lasting friendships through the camaraderie of the bar".

The second was to have been appointed to the bench, and over 20 years he had been learning all the time from his colleagues and from the gifted pleaders who appeared in his court.

Gill said: "To have been Lord President has been an honour. I have tried to live up to the responsibilities of the job in a fitting way... to enhance the reputation of the court... and to make the work of my colleagues more congenial and fulfilling.I leave office with only the happiest of memories of my time as a pleader and my time as a judge."

On the thorny issue of judicial declarations, legal insiders outside court praised Gill for his input on a proposal calling for judges to declare their secretive wealth, connections and links to big business.

For the past two years, Lord Gill fought a very public and bitter battle with the Scottish Parliament concerning MSPs investigations of transparency and accountability in the Scottish judiciary, amid plans to create a register of judicial interests as called for in Petition PE1458: Register of Interests for members of Scotland's judiciary

The proposals to create a register of judicial interests envisages the creation of a single independently regulated register of interests containing information on judges backgrounds, their personal wealth, undeclared earnings, business & family connections inside & outside of the legal profession, offshore investments, hospitality, details on recusals and other information routinely lodged in registers of interest across all walks of public life in the UK and around the world.

Gill refused three invitations to appear before MSPs to give evidence on his intense opposition to a register requiring judges to declare their significant wealth and links to big business.

Faced with a no-show of Scotland’s top judge, members of the Scottish Parliament’s Public Petitions Committee took evidence from Scotland’s first Judicial Complaints Reviewer (JCR) Moi Ali. During questions at the Scottish Parliament’s Petitions Committee, Moi Ali told msps there was little transparency or accountability in Scotland’s judiciary.

At the conclusion of a debate at the Scottish Parliament in October 2014, msps overwhelmingly backed a motion urging the Scottish Government to create a register of judicial interests – reported along with video footage & the official record, here: Debating the Judges

Of Gill’s policy against judicial transparency, one legal insider said: “The public required to see first hand the reaction from the judiciary when they were asked to declare their interests. Lord Gill fulfilled this role perfectly and himself made the case for increased transparency and accountability of judges.”

In response to calls from MSPs to attend the Scottish Parliament, the top judge fired off a barrage of angry letters and refused at least three invitations to face MSPs in public and face questions on his hostility to judicial transparency. The saga led to Gill receiving the nickname Lord No-No.

At a recent hearing of the Scottish Parliament’s Public Petitions Committee, one MSP said Gill had protected vested interests of the judiciary during a two year probe on judicial transparency & accountability.

Previous articles on the lack of transparency within Scotland’s judiciary, investigations by Diary of Injustice including reports from the media, and video footage of debates at the Scottish Parliament’s Public Petitions Committee can be found here : A Register of Interests for Scotland's Judiciary

38 comments:

  1. and fyi they cancelled court business to give all these ridiculous speeches that no one really believes.

    ReplyDelete
  2. Once a judge..He will turn up soon somewhere.

    ReplyDelete
  3. You could always offer him a post at DOI!

    ReplyDelete
  4. Speaking at a conference of Commonwealth Law Reform Agencies in Edinburgh, Lord Carloway said that his proposals to abolish corroboration has been met with “real hostility” from some lawyers.

    Lord Carloway said: “Reactionary or excessively defensive forces among the legal profession can, and often do, behave in a manner obstructive to progressive law reform, especially where there is transparent perceived financial self-interest.”

    Sour grapes from Carloway and now he will be holding the baby while they search for a candidate for Lord President.

    Completely bonkers the whole thing.Gill should have announced retirement and waited on new LP before leaving office.

    ReplyDelete
  5. Loopholes and Oaths anything to cover their tracks, that is the judiciary. The top law holder and his successor are clearly not accountable and will use any means at their disposal to fight transparency. Who the hell runs the show, those elected to parliament or the secretive Judiciary. Some democracy. How the powerful use any means to be unnaccountable. There would be some stink if we really knew what they are up to. I bet my life if someone wrote to their MSP complaining about a judge nothing would be done.

    ReplyDelete
  6. That was quite a savaging of his leaving party!
    Was this one of those councils of the Godfathers in Las Vegas?!

    ReplyDelete
  7. Referring to music - another of Lord Gill's great passions, Wolffe recalled that he had written an anthem, "Populus Sion", for the Faculty of Advocates Choir which was performed by the choir, under his direction, in the Basilica of St Peter in Rome in 2006.

    .. so the old judge prefers conducting an orchestra to revealing his interests,am tempted to say more but well you know and all that etc

    ReplyDelete
  8. For your readers amusement,the joke at the office today:

    They could not afford a flypast by the Red Arrows for Gill's last day so they called in Donald Bruton,former depute clerk at the Court of Session to release a flight of Budgies :)

    ReplyDelete
  9. Lord Carloway said: “Reactionary or excessively defensive forces among the legal profession can, and often do, behave in a manner obstructive to progressive law reform, especially where there is transparent perceived financial self-interest.”

    As in when judges who are obstructive to progressive reforms when there is a transparent perceived financial self interest against a register of judicial interests.

    ReplyDelete
  10. Tribune (noun)

    an official in ancient Rome chosen by the plebeians to protect their interests.

    Tribune Gill will not be chuffed!

    ReplyDelete
  11. From Lord NoNo

    To Lord GoGo

    Ending with Lord Loop-hole


    What a legacy?

    ReplyDelete
  12. Kidded on he was Tribune of the Celeres?

    Acted as if he was Tribune of the Plebs?

    Turns out he was Tribune of the Treasury?

    ReplyDelete
  13. Silly man he could have done the right thing and engage with your petition.Obviously too much to hide!

    ReplyDelete
  14. You should have pitched up to tell them all some home truths although by the sounds of it they would not believe it such are their opinions of themselves.
    Betcha the daggers were out as soon as his back was turned!

    ReplyDelete
  15. Whoever gets the job has a lot of cleaning up to do.However Gill's bad attitude has permanently scarred the judiciary in terms of public trust.Plenty are expressing same although will not want to admit in public.

    ReplyDelete
  16. At the end of the day, the most desirable job in the country is now the most undesirable.

    ReplyDelete
  17. Not as well covered as the Queen's speech was it although as I know some of the seedy backgrounds of characters in attendance there could be some decent headlines on the great pretenders who took part yesterday :)

    ReplyDelete
  18. @22:17

    Wicked observation on Bruton.I suppose you know they only acted because it leaked to the press.Just ask any of the staff who knew he was at it for ages.

    ReplyDelete
  19. Anonymous said...
    and fyi they cancelled court business to give all these ridiculous speeches that no one really believes.

    26 May 2015 at 20:54
    ££££££££££'mmmmm

    I am assuming the expenses and outlays for cancelling Tuesday's scheduled business will come out of The Lord President's fat wallet, given that it was wholly unnecessary and a clear disregard for the cases that were booked in?

    Is there no end to the way regular citizens are ridden roughshod over by people who couldn't give a owls hoot who they upset?

    Typical, I am above the law and the rules do not apply to me, I can just motion with my hand and the plebs will suffer?

    ReplyDelete
  20. Anonymous said...
    Loopholes and Oaths anything to cover their tracks, that is the judiciary. The top law holder and his successor are clearly not accountable and will use any means at their disposal to fight transparency. Who the hell runs the show, those elected to parliament or the secretive Judiciary. Some democracy. How the powerful use any means to be unnaccountable. There would be some stink if we really knew what they are up to. I bet my life if someone wrote to their MSP complaining about a judge nothing would be done.

    26 May 2015 at 21:39
    ()()()()()()()()()()()()()()()()()()()()()

    The Scottish Crown Office have a whole department that deals with cover ups of the type you refer to.

    It's called The National Casework Division and it is headed up by the most twisted and unlawful types who would happily sell their granny if it meant favours from the gravy brigade.

    ReplyDelete
  21. No doubt will pop up again soon and anyway you must have plenty to write about him for some time to come?

    ReplyDelete
  22. Maybe now that the dictator has gone, we can get to the bottom of why he thought that Scottish Judges secrets were more important to protect than the Scottish People?

    Time to open up the cupboards and let the rattling skeletons free?

    ReplyDelete
  23. A jolly old gathering of old blokes who have fleeced clients for decades.Same goes for this Faculty choir,must be funded from ripped off clients and rip off legal fees

    ReplyDelete
  24. I read Carloway's comments about corroboration and his blaming lawyers for the whole mess.SO what has he got to say for his current boss who also stood in the way?
    Whoever gets the job will be just as cantankerous as Gill they are all from the same ilk same pool same grooming and look down on the rest of us as mere plebs here to serve their reign.

    Thank god people like you have the guts to go up front and expose the lot for the bunch of fraudsters and crooks they really are.

    ReplyDelete
  25. @ 26 May 2015 at 22:43

    Good point ...

    @ 27 May 2015 at 14:36

    Feel free to share your info with DOI ...

    @ 27 May 2015 at 17:47

    Lots more to come ...

    ReplyDelete
  26. The only thing missing was some corrupt FIFA officials and a bed sheet to cover them up!

    ReplyDelete
  27. Good to hear it.Keep them on their toes!

    ReplyDelete
  28. @ 28 May 2015 at 00:23

    Swap the FIFA bed sheet for an ermine robe & wig ...

    In response to the unpublished comments relating to a case, this information will be looked into.

    ReplyDelete
  29. Of Gill’s policy against judicial transparency, one legal insider said: “The public required to see first hand the reaction from the judiciary when they were asked to declare their interests. Lord Gill fulfilled this role perfectly and himself made the case for increased transparency and accountability of judges.”

    lol!He certainly did!

    ReplyDelete
  30. I am sure they were all wearing party hats and were scoffing the jelly and ice cream, no doubt covered with lashings of gravy so that they can back-slap each other as they guzzled up like pigs in a trough?

    No doubt the champaign was on tap too?

    ReplyDelete
  31. Now everyone who spoke at this send off will be lobbying for their own choice to get his job

    ReplyDelete
  32. My my all those glowing tributes are at odds with the out of hours groans of his own staff..

    ReplyDelete
  33. Yes the corrupt FIFA crowd will be right at home with this mob and I read your other story on Gill going to Qatar home of the bribes and terrorist banks!No shame eh!

    ReplyDelete
  34. I would like to see the transparency Queen Moi Ali replace Old Gill.

    Now, that would be real Scottish Justice for a change.

    ReplyDelete
  35. If that is Gill gone, how will he follow through with the threats of his SNP lawyer apologist mouth peace, Roseanna Cunningham, that he was watching which MSP's were voting for Mr Cherbi's Petition and he would sort them out?

    ReplyDelete
  36. With the amount of stories the JO are putting out about Gill's departure it is evident the whole thing is down to you.

    One good piece of news - while he may have left us rudderless Gill's method of departure may ensure his deputy does not rise to the top job.

    ReplyDelete
  37. Have you decided on you are backing for the new Lord President?

    ReplyDelete
  38. Congratulations on surviving the onslaught of Lord Gill ;p

    ReplyDelete

Comments should encourage & promote an acceptable & respectful level of public debate on law & legal issues, the judiciary, courts & justice system.

All comments are subject to moderation. Anonymous comments are enabled.
Abusive or unacceptable comments will not be published.
Comments & links to material may not always be published but will be noted and investigated.

Sourced information, news leaks, or cases with verifiable documentation for investigation should be emailed to blog journalists.